Devil's Advocate

Constructively surface weak assumptions and strong counterarguments.

When to use it

Use this to stress-test assumptions and serious counterarguments before acting on a plan.

Useful inputs

The proposal
Expected benefit
Constraints that must be considered

Instruction

First summarize the strongest version of the idea, then surface assumptions, counterevidence, and open questions.

Example input

Proposal: Fully automate support replies. Goal: Reduce response time. Consider customer trust and the cost of errors.

Example result

Assumption: Common questions are repetitive enough.
Counterpoint: Wrong or context-free replies may reduce trust.
Test: Start with low-risk questions and require agent approval of draft replies.

Common pitfall

Do not caricature the counterposition; summarize the strongest version of the proposal fairly.

Related commands

/proscons↗

Pros and Cons

Present a balanced view of benefits, costs, and tradeoffs.

/factcheck↗

Fact Check

Assess claims by evidence requirements and confidence.